What keeps members moving?
Understanding the people behind the membership, and the stories that give them a reason to return.
Paid Connected Fitness subscriptions, down 8.8% year over year.
Year-over-year average workout time per Connected Fitness subscription.
Built around real lives.
The historical hardware-member profile points toward established adults balancing fitness with everyday responsibilities.
Of U.S. Connected Fitness members.
33% ages 35–44; 25% ages 45–54.
Share in this household-income bracket.
More than a workout.
Members describe benefits that reach beyond performance: feeling more confident, improving their relationship with movement, and finding encouragement.
2025 member survey, 1,011 U.S. respondents
62% of Peloton users were inclined to compare themselves with fitness influencers. Achievable examples give these readers a useful reference point.
Three reasons to keep showing up.
Each theme turns an audience insight into a member story, then connects that story to an activity within the service.
A routine you can keep
A weekly member diary shows how different classes fit around real schedules, energy levels, and available time.
Story idea, channels & measurement
The story
“A week of movement, around a full life.”
A member shares their actual schedule, why they chose each session, and a class sequence readers can adapt.
From story to action
Blog diary → weekly email → linked app classes.
Measure: class starts from content and completed workouts in the following week.
Progress you can recognize
Define progress through consistency, confidence, and everyday capability. Let a member tell the story and an instructor explain the next step.
Story idea, channels & measurement
The story
“My first class back.”
A member returns after a break, describes a small milestone, and receives practical instructor guidance.
From story to action
Member profile → instructor advice → relevant session.
Test: confidence-focused versus performance-focused stories; compare relevance and next-class completion.
Belonging on your own terms
Show different ways to feel connected, from a shared class to quiet encouragement from a familiar instructor.
Story idea, channels & measurement
The story
“Together, in your own way.”
Members of different ages, abilities, and participation styles explain how they found a connection.
From story to action
Community story → optional response, shared session, or private participation.
Measure: perceived belonging, voluntary participation, and subsequent class activity.
How to evaluate the content
Use current member feedback to refine these themes, then test whether the stories encourage participation.
Member survey
Explore motivations, perceived value, barriers, and preferred formats. Compare Connected Fitness and app-only members, including frequent and infrequent users.
8–12 interviews
Ask what makes a story encouraging, relevant, or unconvincing, and identify the moment a member decides to try a class.
Randomized content test
Hold the offer, placement, and call to action consistent. Compare relevance, clicks, class starts, and completion; follow renewal over a longer period.
Three questions to guide the next step.
Which benefits best explain perceived subscription value, and how do answers differ by membership type and activity level?
Do stories about everyday confidence and consistency generate greater relevance and next-class participation than athletic-performance stories, and for whom?
Which owned channels and formats best support ongoing participation for members who prefer public community involvement versus private use?
Peloton’s owned content should show how members use the service in everyday life. Stories about fitting in a short workout, returning after a break, or trying a new class can make the value of membership easier to see and give readers a reason to come back.
Read the full analysis
Peloton audience and owned media analysis
The brand story and the audience it needs to serve
Peloton’s brand story centers on making regular exercise easier to sustain through coaching, progress and connection. Its owned media should show how those benefits fit into members’ lives after the equipment purchase. As of June 30, 2026, Peloton had about 5.5 million members worldwide, while paid Connected Fitness subscriptions had fallen 8.8% year over year to 2.553 million (Peloton Interactive, Inc. [Peloton], 2026a, 2026c). My conclusion is that ongoing membership value should be the priority for owned storytelling: give people a reason to return and something useful to do when they get there.
This report uses secondary research to profile Peloton’s existing audience and develop three storytelling themes. It combines company disclosures, member survey findings, YouGov audience research and academic studies. The analysis focuses on current member needs, using the available historical demographic baseline alongside newer behavior and attitude data. The Small Shell student campaign can build on these insights, while the overall brand story must remain relevant to the wider membership.
Demographics and the core audience
Peloton’s disclosed U.S. Connected Fitness profile points toward an established adult audience. In November 2023, women made up 67% of members; ages 35–44 accounted for 33% and ages 45–54 for 25%, totaling 58%. The $100,000–$150,000 household-income bracket represented 24% (Peloton, 2024, slide 15). For owned content, I would prioritize relatable adult routines and people who already invest in fitness. Stories should acknowledge competing demands on time and show how a membership earns its place in everyday life. These choices follow the historical hardware-member profile; app-only users should also appear in the editorial mix.
Psychographics and attitudes
Members value how exercise makes them feel as well as what it helps them achieve. In Peloton’s 2025 survey of 1,011 U.S. members, 93% said their experience improved their relationship with their bodies, 90% reported improved mental health and 85% felt a sense of belonging (Peloton, 2025, p. 12). These self-reported benefits give the brand a strong emotional foundation. Confidence, encouragement and feeling welcome should be recurring subjects. A member learning to enjoy movement or returning to a routine offers a story with clear personal stakes and an outcome readers can recognize.
Behavior and social media practices
The behavior data adds a useful distinction: Peloton is losing subscriptions while continuing to engage users within its subscription base. Average workout time per Connected Fitness subscription rose 7% year over year in Q2 fiscal 2026 (Peloton, 2026b). YouGov (2023) also found that 62% of Peloton users were inclined to compare themselves with fitness influencers. In a study of 663 users, stronger community was associated with more brand-related social activity and more frequent product use (Davies et al., 2024). Together, these findings support content that connects training with social encouragement. Member examples should offer achievable ideas, giving socially engaged readers something useful to follow and discuss.
Three storytelling themes
I recommend three themes for Peloton’s owned channels. Each turns a research finding into a recognizable member experience, with a clear next step into the service. The themes address practical routines, personal progress and community, allowing the brand to speak to different motivations within the same membership.
1 A routine you can keep
The message is that Peloton can help members build a fitness routine around the life they have. Its 2024 investor presentation showed strength training at 24% of workouts in year-to-date 2024 and cycling at 40% (Peloton, 2024, slide 17). That mix gives the brand a concrete story about variety: a membership can serve different kinds of training. The newer increase in average workout time adds a reason to focus on helping members make fuller use of the service (Peloton, 2026b).
A weekly blog and email series should follow one member’s actual schedule, showing how they choose sessions around available time and energy. Each story would include a short explanation of the class sequence and links into the app. The appeal is practical: readers leave with an approach they can adapt without planning everything from scratch. Featuring different routines would also introduce members to activities they have overlooked. Success should be measured through course starts from the content and completed workouts in the following week. That connects the editorial idea directly to participation.
2 Progress you can recognize
This theme defines progress through consistency, confidence and everyday capability. Peloton’s member survey makes those subjects central to its story: respondents connect the service with a better relationship with their bodies and improved mental health (Peloton, 2025). Given the comparison behavior reported by YouGov (2023), I would use attainable member examples and varied definitions of success. An audience already exposed to fitness influencers needs useful reference points for its own progress.
Member profiles could show someone returning after a break, completing an unfamiliar class or learning a movement with an instructor. Each profile should pair the personal experience with practical coaching and an invitation to try a relevant session. Peloton already combines instructor advice with community contributions in its article on workout motivation (Brown West-Rosenthal & Team Peloton, 2024). This format gives the brand a natural voice: a member explains what changed, and a coach helps the reader take a similar first step. Compare a confidence-focused story with a performance-focused version, then assess relevance ratings and next-class completion to learn which audience each serves best.
3 Belonging on your own terms
Peloton should present belonging as something members can experience in different ways. Davies et al. (2024) connect community with social activity and product use. Rutledge et al. (2025), studying 1,036 users, also link emotional connection with personal growth. These findings make community a substantive part of the brand story. The editorial opportunity is to show what encouragement looks like in practice, from a shared class to a familiar instructor helping someone feel comfortable enough to participate.
A community series should feature members of different ages, abilities and participation styles, with instructors explaining how to join a shared session or adapt a workout. Readers could respond to an optional prompt, join an activity or simply follow along privately. Offering these entry points makes the invitation welcoming and respects different comfort levels. Stories should explain how the person found a connection and how it affected their experience. Measure changes in perceived belonging, voluntary participation and subsequent class activity. This keeps community content tied to the member experience it is meant to support.
Research methods and further questions
The research points to a clear editorial direction: help existing members turn access into a routine they value. Workout data supplies the practical side of that story; survey responses explain its emotional importance; community research shows why social connection belongs alongside coaching. The subscription decline makes this direction timely. Peloton needs to keep demonstrating what members gain from returning, and its owned channels are well suited to linking a personal story with a useful next workout.
Methods behind the storytelling approach
Peloton’s annual member survey is a documented example of audience research informing product and content decisions (Peloton, 2025). It gives the company a way to identify feelings and experiences worth exploring in stories. The academic studies also show how surveys can examine relationships among community, motivation and use (Davies et al., 2024; Rutledge et al., 2025). To evaluate individual stories, Peloton could combine those attitudinal measures with content engagement and workout behavior, then use interviews to understand the reasons behind the numbers.
I recommend a member survey covering motivations, perceived value, barriers and preferred formats, with separate analysis for Connected Fitness and app-only members and for different activity levels. Recruiting frequent and infrequent users would make the results more useful for editorial planning. Follow-up interviews with eight to 12 members would explore what makes a story encouraging, relevant or unconvincing. Ask participants to describe the moment they identified with a member, lost interest or decided to try a class. Those details would help the team choose stronger subjects and more useful calls to action.
A randomized email or in-app test would then compare the storytelling options. Keep the offer, placement and call to action consistent, assign members to one version and define the observation period in advance. Relevance ratings would assess the message; click-through, class starts and completion would track the response. A longer follow-up could examine renewal. This sequence gives the content team a practical way to improve stories, moving from what members say matters to the choices they make after reading.
Three research questions
RQ1. Which benefits best explain current members’ perceived subscription value: flexible routines, coaching, measurable progress or social connection, and how do answers differ by membership type and activity level?
RQ2. Do stories centered on everyday confidence and consistency produce greater relevance and next-class participation than stories centered on athletic performance, and for which member groups?
RQ3. Which owned channel and format best supports ongoing participation, and does the answer differ between members who enjoy public community involvement and those who prefer private use?
Implications for the owned media plan
I would use the blog for fuller member stories, email for timely recommendations and the app for the next activity. Each story should make one benefit concrete and give readers an easy way to act on it. The evidence spans different periods: the demographic baseline is from 2023, the attitude figures are company-reported, and the academic studies include socially engaged samples. These boundaries call for varied representation and current member feedback as the plan develops. The main conclusion remains straightforward: Peloton’s owned story should demonstrate how the membership helps people keep moving, recognize progress and feel connected. That gives the brand a consistent narrative with a practical role in members’ lives.
References / APA
Brown West-Rosenthal, L., & Team Peloton. (2024, February 28). Read this the next time you don’t feel like working out. The Output. https://www.onepeloton.com/blog/workout-motivation
Davies, M., Hungenberg, E., Aicher, T. J., & Newland, B. L. (2024). Work[out] from home: Examining brand community among connected fitness brand users. International Journal of Sport Management and Marketing, 24(2), 113–136. https://doi.org/10.1504/IJSMM.2024.137102
Peloton Interactive, Inc. (2024, May). Investor presentation. https://investor.onepeloton.com/static-files/c03e5799-62a2-4f7a-aed3-6eab9bdcf1a6
Peloton Interactive, Inc. (2025). Impact report 2025. https://investor.onepeloton.com/static-files/b8d4d916-0341-4030-9229-8b94386ede6b
Peloton Interactive, Inc. (2026a). Annual report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended June 30, 2026. https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1639825/000163982526000038/pton-20260630.htm
Peloton Interactive, Inc. (2026b, February 5). Peloton announces Q2 FY2026 financial results. https://investor.onepeloton.com/static-files/6445298b-4be2-4351-b54f-1b6ae7aa8e85
Peloton Interactive, Inc. (2026c, August 6). Peloton announces Q4 & FY2026 financial results. https://onepeloton.gcs-web.com/news-releases/news-release-details/peloton-announces-q4-fy2026-financial-results
Rutledge, P., Garner, M., & Collins, H. (2025). Moved by love: Kama muta and personal growth in Peloton users. Media Psychology Review, 11(1). https://mprcenter.org/review/moved-by-love-kama-muta-and-personal-growth-in-peloton-users/
YouGov. (2023, November 3). Peloton partners with NBA and WNBA – What the numbers say. https://yougov.com/en-us/articles/47775-peloton-partners-with-nba-and-wnba-what-the-numbers-say